Tag Archives: Madden

Holiday Turkey

Madden

by George Wolf

Oh, I hate to do it, but I have to throw the flag on Madden, one of the most disappointing movies of the year.

I know, and I was really looking forward to this. It’s from co-writer and director David O. Russell, who is reminding everyone who didn’t know, or may have forgotten, that the Madden in the video game refers to a real person.

John Madden was a Super Bowl winning coach with the Oakland Raiders before he retired, due to health reasons and a demanding schedule, to become a beloved broadcaster, commercial pitchman, and turducken (a deboned chicken stuffed into a deboned duck stuffed into a deboned turkey) connoisseur. He was then recruited by the upstart gaming company EA sports and the name Madden soon became synonymous with a new brand of football.

The ensemble is stellar. You’ve got Nicolas Cage under a bunch of prosthetics playing the eccentric Madden. Christian Bale absolutely nails the equally eccentric persona of Oakland Raiders owner Al Davis, with great support from Kathryn Hahn as John Madden’s wife, Virginia, and Sienna Miller as Al Davis’s wife, Carol. Throw in John Mulaney as EA sports founder Trip Hawkins, and you’ve got a great cast to work with, but Russell starts fumbling from the opening whistle.

The tone is all over the place. It’s part biography, part The Office-style mockumentary. And too much of it looks cheap, like a bad SNL skit where some ex-NFL players and comedian Shane Gillis put on wigs and glasses to stand in as nerdy game developers while Mulaney starts riffing.

It’s awkward and sad, because Russell (Silver Linings Playbook, American Hustle, The Fighter) wastes some great talent and storytelling possibilities. You’ve got really two fascinating relationships to explore here, one between John Madden and Al Davis and one between John Madden and his wife. Plus, you’ve got terrific actors to go exploring with. But Madden goes off the rails from the start. Every avenue seems misguided, and it’s never clear what kind of movie this is trying to be. It’s just too distracted, never giving us a compelling reason to get invested for nearly two hours.

Penalty: unsportsmanlike. Could use a game reset.